In 2025, Good Samaritan’s roughly 100 skilled nursing facilities fielded more than 500 surveys. Some were relatively brief, but a standard recertification survey typically brings a team of state inspectors into a community for the better part of a week, adding to the work administrators and caregivers perform every day. When the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) tested its new risk-based survey (RBS) at Good Samaritan’s Ambassador community in New Hope, Minnesota, a pair of surveyors left after two days without citing a single deficiency.
It was a much more conversational approach, said DeeAndra Sandgren, chief nursing officer of Good Samaritan, which is part of Sanford Health. “Quite often, surveys are very transactional,” she explained. “‘We need this, show us that.’ This one really seemed to be more productive.”
Since early September 2026, communities like Ambassador have been eligible for the RBS. With the goal of incentivizing providers to improve their quality of care, CMS expanded the surveys to providers that meet a demanding set of criteria. Those that do—the nzumber is currently estimated at 12% nationwide—will receive an abbreviated survey from a smaller team. CMS identifies qualifying facilities on the online healthcare comparison tool, Care Compare, with a gold trophy icon.
In the wake of the program’s expansion, Provider spoke with leaders at three organizations whose communities participated in the pilot. They discussed what changed for their staff and residents and how the program supports their existing quality-improvement initiatives.
What Changed
CMS outlined the national program in a July 16, 2026, memo, updated on Sept. 29, 2026. Having tested the approach since 2023 during the Biden administration in more than 100 communities across 22 states, CMS found that a focused survey identified noncompliance as reliably as the standard protocol. Crucially, the RBS covers all the required areas, but surveyors examine a smaller resident sample and conduct fewer survey activities. Each visit involves a smaller team and typically takes half the time of a standard survey. Providers can still expect a visit from surveyors at least once every 15 months, and they should be aware that if concerns or complaints arise during an RBS, surveyors can shift to a full survey.
Holly Harmon, senior vice president of quality, regulatory, and clinical services at the American Health Care Association/National Center for Assisted Living (AHCA/NCAL), called the redesign a matter of common sense. “It really is an uplift for facilities, residents, staff, families, and communities that the process is more streamlined and efficient,” she said, noting that AHCA/NCAL has encouraged this sort of approach.
“CMS and state survey agencies have faced long-standing backlogs. Offering a risk-based survey to high-performing facilities will help distribute oversight resources to where they’re needed most.”
State survey agencies have faced increasing resource constraints, with the budget for survey and certification at a flat $397 million since 2015, according to CMS. By expanding the RBS, regulators hope to mitigate backlogs by allowing surveyors to redirect their attention from high-performing providers to complaint investigations and overdue surveys at other communities.
“Strengthening oversight of long-term care facilities is one of many top priorities at CMS,” said CMS Administrator Dr. Mehmet Oz in the program’s official announcement. “Nursing homes care for our seniors, and that care should be of the utmost quality.”
A High Bar for Eligibility
The RBS program comes with rigorous eligibility criteria. As laid out in Appendix A of the CMS memo, qualifying providers must have a five-star overall rating on Care Compare and at least a three-star staffing rating. They cannot have gone more than 18 months without a standard survey, and they must have passed their previous survey cycle without any citations for actual harm, immediate jeopardy, or substandard quality of care. Staffing waivers are disqualifying, as are failed Payroll-Based Journal or Minimum Data Set audits. Facilities that have changed ownership since the last standard survey are disqualified, and so are Special Focus Facility candidates. Finally, the criteria exclude any communities with two or more residents ages 65 and older who have been diagnosed with schizophrenia since admission, and any whose health inspection score is higher than their state’s 50th percentile. (As CMS notes, lower scores denote higher performance.)
Drawing on June 2026 data, CMS identified 1,560 qualifying facilities out of 14,682 nationwide. As the RBS moves forward, CMS will provide states with updated eligibility lists at the end of every quarter. Facilities will remain eligible for six months after the state receives the list unless a disqualifying event occurs. Qualifying facilities also received a gold trophy icon on Care Compare starting Oct. 8, 2026.
‘Shorter Doesn’t Mean Lighter’
Foundations Health Solutions has undergone multiple risk-based surveys. Tyler Myers, the provider’s director of clinical services, offered one important takeaway: “Shorter doesn’t mean lighter,” he said. “Surveyors covered a lot of ground, and our staff felt they were thorough.” Rather than go through every task involved in a traditional survey, they performed targeted observations, record reviews and staff interviews.
Sandgren reached the same conclusion. Surveyors watched Ambassador’s staff provide care, chatted with residents, and were clear that they would transition to a full survey if any concerns arose.
“I would hate for people to think that a risk-based survey means easier,” she said. “It doesn’t. It just means, hey, things are going well. We know this building has strong performance, and CMS has found a way to keep the oversight meaningful for those locations that display consistent quality.”
At Covenant Living, where one community participated in the RBS pilot, the survey took two days instead of the usual four or five. According to Peggy Connorton, assistant vice president of healthcare regulation, compliance and quality, the smaller survey team—just two people—helped ease the burden that caregivers sometimes feel when a large team of surveyors comes to observe their work. “The team felt it was smoother and less disruptive than a traditional survey, and it still maintained that focus on quality and resident care,” Connorton said.
The streamlined process is especially evident in the medication pass. In a traditional survey, Sandgren explained, surveyors might spend hours watching a nurse conduct the pass and questioning her about every medication. Not so much in the RBS.
“They might only spend 30 minutes watching that med pass if there are no concerns,” Sandgren said. “It doesn’t delay residents getting their medications.”
Giving Time Back to Caregivers and Residents
The RBS gives providers a valuable resource: time. The standard survey lasts four days or longer, straining administrators who are still juggling admissions, discharges, care conferences and more. “All the regular work has to happen, but now with four extra people in your conference room,” Sandgren said.
Those visits add up, especially across large organizations. “Often they’re shorter visits, but each one puts demands on those leaders and pulls them away from their regular job,” Sandgren said, noting that the RBS allows providers to dedicate that time back to care. “Now we’re not pulling nurses off the floor for interviews, and we can go ahead and coach a new caregiver or work on fall prevention or address a resident’s change in condition.”
Myers described the same benefits at Foundations Health Solutions, where the RBS freed up employees to stick to their normal routines and keep their attention focused on residents. “Instead of fielding record requests for days, our leaders can stay on the floor with their staff and residents,” he explained.
Even residents reap the benefits, Sandgren noted, gaining back some of the time they might spend with surveyors in a traditional survey. Myers heard as much from residents who had been through both.
“Some told us this one was less disruptive and that their building still felt like home,” Myers said. “That matters. Facilities should be held accountable for quality and safety, and this process does that while respecting residents’ daily lives.”
More Substantive Conversations
All three providers observed that the RBS makes room for a more productive relationship with surveyors. “Because surveyors have room to focus on higher-risk areas,” Myers said, “our conversations with them have been more substantive, and their feedback has been more useful for making improvements.”
Connorton received similar feedback from the Covenant community that participated in the RBS pilot. “The administrator felt they were able to have good conversations with the surveyors.”
At Good Samaritan’s Ambassador community, employees came away from the survey with confidence in their work. “Staff really felt that it was a collaborative effort and not a punitive one,” Sandgren said. “We don’t always get to hear from surveyors that you’re doing a good job, but when the survey comes, they’re in and out in two days. It just really reinforces that our staff are doing good work every day, that they’re prepared, and our residents are getting excellent quality of care.”
The Gold Trophy
One noteworthy feature of the expanded RBS is the gold trophy icon on Care Compare, which denotes high-performing facilities that qualify for the program. The three providers had differing perspectives about the message it sends to families, though they agreed it provides a valuable signal to caregivers.
For Sandgren, the trophy offers reassurance to families trying to make a stressful decision for their loved ones. “I love that that trophy icon can give them a clear indicator: ‘Hey, this facility is recognized as having high quality,’” she said.
At the same time, she doesn’t want families to take the inverse message from the red hand symbol next to facilities cited for abuse, stressing that these icons are one piece of a bigger picture. Ultimately, she hopes families visit any community they’re considering. “We want them to come in, get a tour, get to know our teams and how we take care of their loved one,” she said.
Myers offered a more measured perspective on the presence of the icon, suggesting that families are more likely to choose a provider based on the physical facility itself, its reputation in the community, and any recommendations they’ve received. Still, he feels the gold trophy will provide a morale boost internally.
“Caregivers hear far more about what goes wrong in this industry than what goes right, and being able to say they work in a gold trophy building is something to be proud of,” he said. “Even in a small way, that kind of pride can help with morale, job satisfaction and retention.”
Connorton’s sentiments were similar. “For our employees, it can give us a sense of pride and just reinforce that their daily work results in success and quality outcomes.”
Recognizing Excellence
Another important benefit of the RBS program is the incentive it offers to facilities that don’t qualify—yet.
That’s how Foundations Health Solutions sees it. “Those that want to become eligible have a real reason to improve their outcomes,” Myers explained. “We plan to use it that way within our own organization, as a goal for every one of our buildings. Across the industry, that kind of incentive encourages quality improvement well beyond the facilities already in the program.”
He argued that the program’s value extends far beyond the improved efficiencies and reduced backlogs. “The bigger shift is that the survey process now recognizes differences in provider performance,” he said. “We operate in Ohio, where a meaningful share of Medicaid reimbursement already depends on quality performance. We support that, because quality should have consequences. It’s encouraging to see CMS bring the same principle to oversight.”
Meanwhile, at Good Samaritan, Sandgren is already hearing from staff asking how their own facilities can become eligible.
“From our perspective, the best-quality programs hold organizations accountable and recognize excellence,” she concluded. “I think this has the potential to support both.”
Steve Manning is a journalist based in New York City.